Wall Street Has 38 Buy Ratings on Shopify and One Sell. But We Disagree.

The post Wall Street Has 38 Buy Ratings on Shopify and One Sell. But We Disagree. appeared first on 24/7 Wall St..

Our 24/7 Wall St. price target for Shopify (NASDAQ:SHOP) is $106.90, which sits just below the current quote of $112.49. That implies -4.97% downside over the next 12 months, and our model carries a 90% confidence reading. The call is hold. Shopify is a high-quality compounder trading near fair value after a sharp reset.

24/7 Wall St. Price Target Summary

Why We Could Be Wrong

Our 24/7 Wall St. price target of $106.90 sits below current levels, and the stock is one of the more divisive names in commerce software. Real upside could come from faster monetization of AI tools like Sidekick and the Universal Commerce Protocol, or from continued strength in Shop Pay, where Q4 GMV grew 62%. Wall Street’s consensus target of $149.78 sits well above our number.

A Brutal Reset, Then a Recovery Attempt

SHOP is down 30.12% year to date, but has rallied 12.18% in the past month and 3.93% in the latest session. Shares trade 18% below the 52-week high of $182.19 and well off the low of $94.

Q1 2026 was operationally excellent. Revenue grew 34.32% to $3.17 billion, beating consensus by 2.74%. Operating income surged 88.18% to $382 million, free cash flow hit $476 million at a 15% margin, and GMV rose 35% to $100.74 billion.

The headline GAAP loss of $581 million was driven entirely by $941 million in mark-to-market equity investment losses. Underlying net income was roughly $360 million. Management expanded the buyback to $5 billion in early June.

Why Bulls See a Breakout Ahead

The bull case rests on AI commerce leadership and operating leverage. Shopify is rolling out Sidekick, Catalog, and the Universal Commerce Protocol while Shop Pay GMV grew 62% and B2B GMV grew 96% in 2025.

With 38 Buy ratings, 12 Holds, and only 1 Sell, the Street’s $149.78 target sets the upper bound. Our bull scenario projects $176.57 by June 2027, a 56.97% return.

The Risks Worth Watching

The bear thesis starts with valuation. SHOP trades at a P/E of 106 and a forward P/E of 57, leaving little margin for error. Q2 guidance for high-twenties revenue growth marks deceleration.

Transaction and loan losses jumped to $148 million in Q3 2025 as the Capital book expands, and CEO Tobias Lutke sold 95,817, 72,000, and 23,813 share tranches into weakness. Our bear case points to $100.21.

Shopify Price Prediction 2026-2030

The 24/7 Wall St. price target is $106.90, the recommendation is hold, and confidence is 90%. The tipping factor is the gap between a trailing multiple north of 100x and forward EPS of less than $1.

The bull trigger would be Q2 revenue reacceleration paired with AI tools meaningfully lifting take rates. The bear trigger would be rising loan losses or guidance slipping into the low twenties. For now, the setup favors patience while the buyback works.

These projections assume Shopify executes on its AI commerce strategy and operating leverage continues to build. Upside could come from faster monetization of Sidekick and Shop Pay, while downside hinges on rising credit losses in the Capital portfolio and tariff-driven GMV pressure.

The post Wall Street Has 38 Buy Ratings on Shopify and One Sell. But We Disagree. appeared first on 24/7 Wall St..